Award Expert

"Ann Lee" Trailer: Best Picture Nomination Incoming?

Share:
Amanda Seyfried in "The Testament of Ann Lee"

Searchlight Pictures has finally unveiled the first full trailer for The Testament Of Ann Lee. Written and directed by Mona Fastvold, the musical period drama explores the founder of the Shaker movement, Ann Lee, played by Amanda Seyfried. She's surrounded by an enticing ensemble including Christopher Abbott, Lewis Pullman, Thomasin McKenzie, and Tim Blake Nelson.

The trailer transports us to an unforgiving eighteenth century. Seyfried looks to be delivering what could be her greatest performance to date, channeling both spiritual ecstasy and human fragility. The film seeks to explore the power of the woman whose grief and pure devotion gave shape to the religious Shaker movement. The trailer delivers one striking image after another: an array of candlelit scenes portraying gatherings and festivities, piercing New England landscapes, and dusky, foreboding glimpses of despair. Cinematographer William Rexer's film photography is perhaps the real standout here.

"Ann Lee"'s Awards chances

The musical elements of the film give The Testament of Ann Lee a singular identity, and are perhaps the kind of daring choices that will stand out to academy voters. The score is front-and-center, crafted by last year's Oscar winner, Daniel Blumberg. And with the inclusion of an original song, that's two potential nominations for the Academy's music branch to award. The prominent role the score plays in the story may assist it towards a nomination.

Amanda Seyfried's career has been building toward a role like this, coming off the heels of her Oscar nominated supporting role in David Fincher’s Mank, as well as her acclaimed performance in The Dropout. This appears to be her biggest and boldest transformation to date.  She sits at #4 in Award Expert's aggregated community predictions with 62% predicting a nomination. While the share of users predicting her is down 7% over the last thirty days, the trailer could give her a rebound.

Perhaps the film's key asset this season is the distributor Searchlight Pictures. They hold a strong track record in getting films across the Best Picture finish line year after year. Previous success include the Oscar-winning Nomadland, The Shape Of Water and Birdman , as well as nominations for The Banshees Of Inisherin, Poor Things and Nightmare Alley. It's hard to count Searchlight out of the race, and with the their only other credible contenders being Is This Thing On? and Rental Family, it's clear Ann Lee's got their best shot. Expect them to go all-in.

If there’s one challenge ahead, it's accessibility. The film is deliberately paced and meditative, potentially making it a tough sit for casual moviegoers. We've also seen a wide range of reactions coming out of festivals. Some hail it as one of the year's best films, while others left feeling cold and indifferent. But reviews are positive overall, holding a 3.6 on Letterboxd with a significant amount of 4.5/5 ratings. It also boasts 89% on Rotten Tomatoes and 77 on Metacritic. To land in Best Picture, it helps tremendously to have voters rank your film at number one on the ballot. Given the passion from some viewers, Ann Lee might benefit from this system.

Currently the film sits at #14 on the award expert app with 12% of users anticipating a nomination. Watch out for an uptick after this trailer. As Searchlight's primary horse in the race with the potential to score nominations in Best Actress and various craft categories, The Testament Of Ann Lee has the potential to break into one of the ten Best Picture slots.

Predictions from Award Expert users

Best Picture

2026 Academy Awards

5,391 usersNov 7, 6:29 AM
One Battle After Another
1

One Battle After Another

Warner Bros.

WIN:83%
7%
change over 30 days
NOM:99%
Sinners
2

Sinners

Warner Bros.

WIN:6%
5%
change over 30 days
NOM:98%
Hamnet
3

Hamnet

Focus Features

WIN:7%
NOM:95%
Marty Supreme
4

Marty Supreme

A24

WIN:1%
NOM:95%
3%
change over 30 days
Sentimental Value
5

Sentimental Value

Neon

WIN:1%
1%
change over 30 days
NOM:94%
Wicked: For Good
6

Wicked: For Good

Universal

WIN:1%
NOM:91%
3%
change over 30 days
It Was Just an Accident
7

It Was Just an Accident

Neon

WIN:0%
NOM:82%
13%
change over 30 days
Frankenstein
8

Frankenstein

Netflix

WIN:0%
NOM:71%
34%
change over 30 days
Avatar: Fire and Ash
9

Avatar: Fire and Ash

20th Century Studios

WIN:0%
NOM:62%
16%
change over 30 days
Bugonia
10

Bugonia

Focus Features

WIN:0%
NOM:52%
No Other Choice
11

No Other Choice

Neon

WIN:0%
NOM:43%
4%
change over 30 days
Jay Kelly
12

Jay Kelly

Netflix

WIN:0%
NOM:18%
5%
change over 30 days
Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere
13

Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere

20th Century Studios

WIN:0%
NOM:13%
38%
change over 30 days
The Testament of Ann Lee
14

The Testament of Ann Lee

Searchlight

WIN:0%
NOM:12%
2%
change over 30 days
The Secret Agent
15

The Secret Agent

Neon

WIN:0%
NOM:8%
4%
change over 30 days

What users are saying

Profile
@gbellie03

i'm at such a loss for these bottom 3 slots but i'm going with my gut based on what i've observed in previous years and the fact that this is still searchlight's biggest contender. even with somewhat mixed reception, it still has higher sco …

Picture

2026 Academy Awards

One Battle After Another
1
Marty Supreme
2
Hamnet
3
Sentimental Value
4
Sinners
5
It Was Just an Accident
6
Wicked: For Good
7
Avatar: Fire and Ash
8
No Other Choice
9
The Testament of Ann Lee
10
Profile
@maxxximus

ANN LEE IS BACK ON THE MENU?!

Profile
@donovanwatchesmovies

9.30.2025: Do you have a moment to talk about our lord and savior Searchlight?

Actress

2026 Academy Awards

Amanda Seyfried
1
Jessie Buckley
2
Renate Reinsve
3
Cynthia Erivo
4
Emma Stone
5
Profile
@cammattox

Sounding more like a Best Actress movie than a Best Picture one.

Actress

2026 Academy Awards

Jessie Buckley
1
Renate Reinsve
2
Amanda Seyfried
3
Cynthia Erivo
4
Emma Stone
5
Profile
@donovanwatchesmovies

8.31.2025: When are we expecting actual reviews? 👀

Actress

2026 Academy Awards

Amanda Seyfried
1
Jessie Buckley
2
Renate Reinsve
3
Emma Stone
4
Cynthia Erivo
5
Profile
@sam_ennis23

This could become an absolute, pretentious mess. I can see all the songs falling flat. But then again, that was basically Emilia Perez, and we all saw what happened there…..

Picture

2026 Academy Awards

Wicked: For Good
5
One Battle After Another
6
Marty Supreme
7
Bugonia
8
It Was Just an Accident
9
Frankenstein
10
Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere
11
After the Hunt
12
Avatar: Fire and Ash
13
The Testament of Ann Lee
14
Profile
@lisanalgaib

Right now, I’m viewing The Testament of Ann Lee as this year’s The Brutalist. I think it will be very competitive in Actress and Director. It’s not a lock since we still have to see how it does at the Festivals and what folks are saying, bu …

Picture

2026 Academy Awards

Sentimental Value
1
Sinners
2
Bugonia
3
Marty Supreme
4
Jay Kelly
5
The Testament of Ann Lee
6
No Other Choice
7
Rental Family
8
Wicked: For Good
9
Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere
10
Profile
@iason.moschos

I have a feeling that this will be incredible along with a great Amanda Seyfried performance

Picture

2026 Academy Awards

Sentimental Value
1
Sinners
2
Jay Kelly
3
Rental Family
4
Bugonia
5
Wicked: For Good
6
Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere
7
Marty Supreme
8
The Testament of Ann Lee
9
One Battle After Another
10
Profile
@ava_saks

Have her in but still need that release date

Actress

2026 Academy Awards

Renate Reinsve
1
Julia Roberts
2
Cynthia Erivo
3
Emma Stone
4
Amanda Seyfried
5
Profile
@ava_saks

Need that beautiful release date

Director

2026 Academy Awards

One Battle After Another
6
Jay Kelly
7
After the Hunt
8
Frankenstein
9
The Testament of Ann Lee
10
Profile
@louispurves

She is going to be singing obvs depends on the film being good but if its the real deal and gets a bunch of nominations she will win

Actress

2026 Academy Awards

Amanda Seyfried
1
Renate Reinsve
2
Julia Roberts
3
Rose Byrne
4
Jessie Buckley
5
Profile
@economyman

Don’t understand the hype for this one (yet). The movie itself sounds awesome but I don’t think it screams “Oscars”

Picture

2026 Academy Awards

It Was Just an Accident
10
Avatar: Fire and Ash
11
Frankenstein
12
Bugonia
13
The Smashing Machine
14
A House of Dynamite
15
Hamnet
16
No Other Choice
17
Ballad of a Small Player
18
The Testament of Ann Lee
19
Profile
@jwosnmmaa

i can see this winning but i think this was be the director/actress winner instead. i think it won’t make me worried if this doesn’t get the Golden Lion because either way like The Brutalists it’s going to be just fine. i think it will plac …

Golden Lion (Best Film)

2025 Venice

Jay Kelly
1
The Testament of Ann Lee
2
The Voice of Hind Rajab
3
Profile
@jwosnmmaa

probably the only film i see giving slight pressure to Sinners. might win BAFTA or something. i didn’t know if they would be willing to nominate Daniel Blumberg so quickly after winning but the score isn’t going to be huge. not just because …

Score

2026 Academy Awards

Sinners
1
The Testament of Ann Lee
2
Frankenstein
3
A House of Dynamite
4
Bugonia
5
Profile
@jwosnmmaa

even though i think it’s a huge contender musical almost never get nominated for screenplay. I mean with had 2 last year but original screenplay is too packed for this to sneak in. maybe could move to adapted?

Original Screenplay

2026 Academy Awards

Marty Supreme
6
A House of Dynamite
7
It Was Just an Accident
8
Is This Thing On?
9
The Testament of Ann Lee
10
Profile
@jhunter64

Became my most anticipated movie in the span of like 2 days, also got really bullish on it’s awards prospects. We’ll see if this pans out

Picture

2026 Academy Awards

Sinners
1
Sentimental Value
2
Marty Supreme
3
Rental Family
4
Jay Kelly
5
Bugonia
6
The Testament of Ann Lee
7
Wicked: For Good
8
One Battle After Another
9
No Other Choice
10
Profile
@adamirwin

Again I just feel like this is gonna trailblaze the fall festivals.

People's Choice Award

2025 TIFF People's Choice Awards

The Testament of Ann Lee
1
Rental Family
2
The Smashing Machine
3
Profile
@adamirwin

Gonna be amazing and will probably blow everyone there away.

Golden Lion (Best Film)

2025 Venice

The Testament of Ann Lee
1
No Other Choice
2
Orphan
3
Profile
@lisanalgaib

Amanda Seyfried Oscar campaign ramps up at Venice and she goes along with Mona Fastvold giving The Testament of Ann Lee 2 big wins

COPPA VOLPI for Best Actress

2025 Venice

Amanda Seyfried
1
Profile
@belangiajo

I’m bullish on Tim Blake Nelson getting a nomination as long as The Testament of Ann Lee is as good as it looks. Mona Fastvold SPECIFICALLY name dropped him as one of the great actors in the film.

Supporting Actor

2026 Academy Awards

Stellan Skarsgård
1
Andrew Garfield
2
Adam Sandler
3
Stephen Graham
4
Tim Blake Nelson
5

Make your predictions on

Award Expert

Award Expert App Icon
App Store LinkPlay Store Link
Share: